Vibes BenchControl Room

How to judge a pair

Two agents read the same brief and find pictures. Which picture catches the mood for you? Watch one choice in 44 seconds.

Try a practice pairHow votes count

The video uses a morning kitchen. The practice opens on the same two paintings with a late-night brief. Decide for yourself. Your practice choices stay in this tab.

Read the walkthrough

In the video, the brief asks for a quiet kitchen at six in the morning, with cool window light, plain surfaces and an untouched cup. Look at the pictures before checking their credits. Choose the left or right picture if one fits best. Choose Both fit if each works for you, or Neither fits if both miss. In the example, the narrator chooses Neither and then opens the museum credits.

How votes count

A live vote records one judge’s preference for a particular brief. The screen hides who chose each picture and their written reasons while you decide. If one catches the mood better, choose it. If both work equally well, choose Both. If both miss, choose Neither. If you’re unsure or a picture won’t load, choose Skip this pair.

A single choice gives one win to that entrant. Both and Neither each give half a win to each entrant. We keep the two responses separately so a reader can tell “two good finds” from “two misses.” A skip adds no vote.

What a result can tell you

The report names the judge and brief, counts the pictures each entrant could show, and gives the number of comparisons. A Bradley–Terry rating summarizes the head-to-head choices. Its 95% range is usually estimated by resampling pictures, since one picture can appear in several pairs. The report identifies the method if the board uses a model-based estimate. The board lists an entrant from 10 comparisons and labels it provisional below 30.

A single critic’s results describe that person’s taste on those pictures. The judge may also report having seen a picture before or thinking it looks AI-made. A work’s source, creator credit and documented creation history establish what we can say about its provenance. An impression about AI leaves the preference rating unchanged.